How to Read People Like the CIA in Business and Life

andrew bustamante

To read people like the CIA, stop trusting the polished first impression and watch for the person who shows up later, when time, energy or money is running low and the public mask gets harder to hold. Former CIA officer Andrew Bustamante teaches a practical system built on that idea: three lives everyone lives, a resource-depletion lens, four working temperaments and a set of disarming questions. This guide explains each tool, what research supports and what it doesn’t, and how to use it to hire, lead and connect better without crossing into manipulation.

It’s nine o’clock on a Tuesday, the final interview of the morning. The candidate is excellent. Firm handshake, well-researched answers, a story about turning a struggling client around that makes you nod. You hire him that afternoon.

Three months later it’s 6:40 in the evening, a deadline has slipped, a client is angry, and you’re watching a different man. Short with the junior staff. Defensive when questioned. Quietly blaming the team for a call he made.

He didn’t lie to you in the interview. You simply met one version of him, and it was the version he’d prepared.

Andrew Bustamante, a former CIA intelligence officer who now teaches spy skills to civilians on his YouTube channel and in his book Outsmart Everyone, builds his method for reading people around exactly that gap. The background to his career and his wider philosophy is covered in the profile of Andrew Bustamante, the CIA officer who turned spy skills into life mastery. His wider idea, the builder versus survivor mindset, shapes how he thinks about people too. This piece is about one skill: seeing people more accurately, sooner.

How Do You Read People Like the CIA?

Reading people like an intelligence officer means looking past the version someone presents and observing how they behave across contexts, especially when they’re tired, pressed for time or under strain. It relies less on decoding body language and more on patterns: consistency between early and late answers, how people handle unexpected questions, and which version of them appears when their resources are low.

In Bustamante’s framing, the skill rests on four tools: understanding the three lives everyone lives, using resource depletion as a lens, recognising four working temperaments, and asking questions that disarm rehearsed answers. None of them requires a badge. All of them require attention.

The Three Lives Everyone Lives

Bustamante starts with a simple model. Everyone lives three lives at once.

The public life is the curated version: the person at work, in the interview, on LinkedIn, at the client dinner. It’s not fake, but it’s managed. The private life is the more relaxed self that shows up with family, close friends and people who’ve earned trust. The secret life is the self that emerges when the usual resources run out: under pressure, exhaustion or fear, when there’s no energy left for presentation.

The mistake most of us make is judging a person’s private or secret life by the standards of their public one, or assuming the public version is the whole story. The candidate in the interview was living his public life, as candidates should. The man at 6:40 p.m. was closer to his secret one.

This isn’t cynicism. You live three lives too, and the people who love you have seen all of them. Reading people well is mostly about remembering that the version in front of you is one slice, and staying curious about the rest.

Why People Show Their True Selves When They’re Running Low

The heart of Bustamante’s method is what he calls resource depletion. When people are fully resourced, he argues, they can perform almost any personality they choose. When those resources run low, the performance slips, and their natural tendencies show.

He names three resources. Time, because schedules reveal priorities and people under time pressure drop the niceties. Energy, because holding a persona takes effort; behaviour at the end of a long day often looks very different from behaviour at nine in the morning. And money, because financial stress shapes decisions, moods and risk-taking. That’s why, in his view, the most revealing conversations often happen later in the day, deeper into a process, or when the stakes are real. For more on the energy side of this, there’s his CIA energy rule for why you’re always tired, and Evy Poumpouras, another former agent, makes a similar point about overloaded minds in the bathtub theory of cognitive load.

There’s solid neuroscience behind at least the energy part. At the University of California, Berkeley, Matthew Walker and colleagues kept volunteers awake for about 35 hours and then scanned their brains as they looked at upsetting images. The brain’s emotional alarm centre was over 60 per cent more reactive than in people who’d slept, and its connection to the prefrontal regions that normally calm it down appeared to weaken.

What that means in practice is useful in both directions. When someone you’re reading is exhausted, you are probably seeing less filtered reactions, so pay attention. And when you are exhausted, your own reactions are less filtered, which is a good reason not to make important judgements about people, or have hard conversations, on no sleep. The link between sleep and success is as much about how you treat people as how you work.

What the Science Supports, and Where It’s Thinner

It’s worth being honest about one part of this. For years, psychologists believed self-control drew on a limited reserve that could be “depleted” by earlier effort, an idea called ego depletion. In 2016, Martin Hagger and colleagues ran the same depletion experiment across 23 laboratories with more than 2,000 participants, and found an effect so small it was statistically indistinguishable from zero.

That doesn’t make Bustamante’s observation wrong. Real fatigue, real deadlines and real money worries clearly change how people behave, and the sleep research above shows how. It does mean the tidy laboratory version of “willpower runs out” isn’t a reliable foundation, so treat depletion as a practical lens, not a law. The honest answer about whether willpower is limited is more nuanced, and more encouraging, than the old theory suggested.

The same calibration applies to personality tests, which come next.

Personality Types: A Map, Not a Verdict

Bustamante uses the Myers-Briggs framework, the familiar sixteen types built on four pairs of preferences, such as introversion versus extraversion. His twist is that each type has a public and a private version, which effectively doubles the picture: the same person may present as organised and outgoing at work and quietly spontaneous at home.

That twist is the useful part, because it reminds you not to freeze anyone into a single label. It’s also worth knowing that personality researchers have long been sceptical of the Myers-Briggs itself. Organisational psychologist Ronald Riggio is among those who point out that traits like introversion run on a sliding scale rather than in two boxes, that people’s results can shift when they retake the test, and that there’s little evidence it predicts job performance.

So use types the way an officer uses a rough map of unfamiliar ground: a starting point that helps you form questions, never a conclusion that replaces looking. If you’d like a simpler lens for how people handle feelings, the four emotional types offer a complementary view.

The Four Temperaments: Lions, Foxes, Cheetahs and Bears

For building teams, Bustamante uses a four-animal framework that’s easy to remember.

Lions are organisers. They plan, structure and handle logistics, and they’re at home in project management. Foxes are creators. They generate options, innovate and see possibilities; they suit product and creative strategy. Cheetahs are executors. They decide fast and act, which makes them natural in sales and operations. Bears are relationship builders. They read the room, hold teams together and shine in people-facing roles.

His central claim is about balance: a high-performing team needs all four. A team of Lions plans beautifully and launches nothing; a team of Cheetahs moves fast in five directions at once; a team without Bears burns people out; a team without Foxes repeats last year. The practical move is to audit your team honestly and recruit for the temperament that’s missing, not the one you like best. It’s a natural companion to the power team pyramid and to building the psychological safety that lets high-performing teams speak up.

Five Interview Questions That Reveal Real Personality

Candidates arrive in public-life mode, with rehearsed answers to predictable questions, and they’re working hard on the first impression you’re forming. Ask “Are you organised?” and everyone says yes. Bustamante’s solution is disarming questions: ones people haven’t prepared for, which reveal how they actually think.

“How would you plan your ideal vacation?”

The answers tend to sort by temperament. A Lion researches destinations, compares prices and builds an itinerary. A Fox lists three wildly different places and loves all of them. A Cheetah is on the next plane. A Bear goes wherever the people they love want to go. There’s no right answer, only an honest one.

“Describe your closet right now, not your ideal closet”

This shows how someone really organises their private space, and whether they’ll describe it honestly or polish it. The honesty matters more than the tidiness.

“When was the last time you were offended?”

This reveals triggers, values and boundaries. Bustamante advises saving it until rapport exists, because asked too early it feels like an ambush.

“What would you do with unlimited resources for one day?”

Remove the constraints and priorities show. Some people build, some give, some rest, some gather the people they love.

“Tell me about a time you failed and what you learned”

This one is familiar, but it still works when you listen for ownership. Watch whether the failure is genuinely theirs, and whether the lesson changed anything.

The Four-Phase Interview: From Public to Private Life

Bustamante structures a revealing conversation in four phases. First, build common ground for fifteen to twenty minutes, finding real shared interests so the person relaxes. Second, ask disarming questions for ten to fifteen minutes, the kind above, so rehearsed answers run out; investigators and negotiators rely on similar conversation techniques that let people convince themselves. Third, let resources deplete naturally: longer interviews, later in the day, or a second conversation at a different time. Fourth, observe inconsistencies, comparing what someone said early with what they say later, and how their manner shifts when they’re tired.

The same structure works outside hiring. A first date, a negotiation, a new business partner or a new neighbour all show you a public life first. Patience lets the rest arrive.

Why Gut Reads Fail: Look for Inconsistency, Not Tells

Popular advice on reading people leans heavily on body language: crossed arms, eye contact, the glance to the left that supposedly gives a liar away. The research is humbling.

When Charles Bond and Bella DePaulo pooled studies involving more than 24,000 people judging whether others were lying, the average accuracy was about 54 per cent, barely better than a coin toss. More striking still, experts such as police officers and investigators did not reliably do better than everyone else.

That finding is why Bustamante’s approach, built on patterns across time and context rather than single tells, is more defensible than most “read anyone instantly” advice. You’re unlikely to catch a lie from a twitch. You’re far more likely to notice that the story at 6 p.m. doesn’t match the story at 9 a.m. The same principle, establishing someone’s normal baseline before reading changes, sits at the heart of reading people like a mentalist. It’s also a reminder that your nervous system’s instant read of who’s safe can be wrong, however certain it feels.

Five mistakes follow from ignoring this. Treating the public persona as the truth. Asking only direct questions, which get rehearsed answers. Meeting people only when they’re fully resourced, so you see only their best behaviour. Ignoring team composition in favour of individual brilliance. And expecting people to be identical across work, home and stress, when everyone shows different slices in different places.

The red flags Bustamante looks for are patterns too: answers that shift between the start and the end of a conversation, an inability to give a genuine answer to a disarming question, a constant focus on sounding good, little self-awareness, and blame that always points elsewhere. The green flags are the reverse: honest, sometimes unflattering answers, self-awareness, consistency, thoughtful pauses and ownership of mistakes.

Reading People at Work, at Home and Everywhere Else

For hiring managers, the method is straightforward: decide which temperament the role and team need, prepare disarming questions in advance, watch how candidates respond to the unexpected, and compare them on consistency rather than polish. For team leaders, it means knowing the temperaments you already have and matching work to them: structure for Lions, open problems for Foxes, urgent tasks for Cheetahs, people-facing work for Bears. Reading your team this way is one of the core skills of emotional intelligence in leadership.

Bustamante also describes how officers build rapport by adjusting their style to the person in front of them. With a Bear, lead with the relationship; with a Cheetah, get to the result. The goal is to make the other person feel understood, so they choose to be more open. That’s the same insight behind making conversations about the other person and much of the science of charisma.

At home, the lens is gentler but just as useful. Recognising when your partner or child is depleted, and not judging their exhausted self by their rested self’s standards, prevents many arguments before they start. The same thinking applies in medicine, sales, teaching and customer service: anyone who works with people does better when they see which version of the person is in front of them, and what that person needs right now.

Build Your Own Read-People Practice

You won’t learn this from one article. Bustamante’s approach is to practise deliberately and keep refining.

Start by keeping simple notes on the people you work with closely: your best guess at their temperament, how they differ in public and private, what stresses them and what they’re like when they’re depleted. Then develop five to ten signature questions for your own field, disarming ones that fit your industry. Test them first in low-stakes conversations, and notice when your predictions about someone turn out right or wrong. Remembering details matters more than it sounds, which is why the shampoo-bottle trick for remembering names and the lost art of real listening do more for your reads than any framework.

You’ll know you’re improving when your predictions about people start coming true more often, when hiring decisions age well, and when someone says, unprompted, that you really get them. Treat every misread as data. The men who read people best stay students: curious, humble about their mistakes, and willing to change their minds.

Here’s a ten-minute practice to try tonight. Pick one person you’ll see this week. Write down which of their three lives you’ve mostly seen, your best guess at their temperament, and one disarming question you’ll ask them, then ask it and just listen. Whatever you learn, write one line afterwards about what surprised you.

The Ethics: Understanding, Not Manipulation

Any tool for reading people can be used to exploit them. Scheduling a hard conversation for the end of someone’s day so they’ll give in, or using what you learn about their private life against them, is manipulation, and it tends to destroy the trust it exploits.

The line Bustamante draws is the right one: use these skills to build real relationships, hire people who’ll thrive, and help others succeed. Don’t use them to corner people, betray confidences or take advantage of someone at their lowest. It’s worth knowing the archetypes of influence running every relationship, and choosing which one you want to be.

Done well, reading people isn’t about gaining an edge over them. It’s about meeting them sooner and more accurately, which is a gift to both of you.

The Man Who Actually Sees People

Go back to that 9 a.m. interview. The candidate wasn’t the problem, and neither were you. You simply met his public life and treated it as the whole man.

Next time, you’ll do it differently. You’ll build some common ground, ask the question he didn’t prepare for, meet him again later in the day, and notice whether his story holds. You’ll judge him by patterns, not tells, and you’ll remember that you’re showing him a public version of yourself too.

None of this makes you suspicious. It makes you observant, patient and fair, three qualities that intelligence work and good leadership share. Who in your working life have you only ever met at nine in the morning?

Questions for the Man Who Wants to Read People Like the CIA

Answer each of these twice: once about someone you work with, and once about yourself. The gap between the two answers is usually the most useful part.

  1. Think of the last three people you misjudged: which of their lives did you meet first, public, private or secret, and when did you first see another one?
  2. Without blaming yourself for those misreads, what has trusting a polished first impression gained you, and what has it charged you?
  3. Recall the last time you were offended, the question saved for later in an interview: where did the heat show up first, face, neck or chest?
  4. If most people spot lies at little better than a coin toss, which of your own public-life habits would you drop so others meet the real you sooner?
  5. Which temperament would your team say you are, Lion, Fox, Cheetah or Bear, and which one is your team most visibly missing?
  6. If most interviews only ever meet people’s public lives, what would a hiring process ten times better at seeing the real person look like, and who would it help?
  7. A year from now someone tells you “you really get me”: what will you have practised, week after week, to earn that sentence?

Stop, Start, Keep: 5 Questions to Read People Better This Week

Use these as a simple stop–start–keep review, with one idea to build on and one release for the reads you get wrong.

  1. Which snap judgement will you stop making this week, such as deciding about a candidate or new colleague in the first ten minutes, and what will you do instead?
  2. In your next one-to-one or interview, which disarming question will you start asking, the vacation, the closet or the failure, and how will you simply listen to the answer?
  3. Which way of paying attention to people already works for you, remembering names, taking notes, noticing moods, and how will you keep it going under pressure?
  4. Tonight, sketch your ten-times-better interview from question six on one page: who involved in hiring at your company will you show it to before Friday?
  5. When a read on someone turns out wrong, what will you tell yourself so it becomes data for the next read rather than a reason to stop trying?

Reading people well isn’t about catching them out. It’s about meeting them sooner.

Frequently Asked Questions About Reading People Like the CIA

How do you read people like the CIA?

Former CIA officer Andrew Bustamante teaches reading people through patterns rather than tells. Remember that everyone lives public, private and secret lives; observe people when their time, energy or money is running low; ask disarming questions they haven’t rehearsed; and compare early and late answers for consistency. Personality and temperament frameworks help you form questions, not conclusions.

What are the three lives everyone lives?

In Bustamante’s model, the public life is the curated self people show at work or in interviews, the private life is the more relaxed self they show to trusted people, and the secret life is the self that emerges under pressure, exhaustion or fear. Reading people well means not mistaking the public version for the whole person.

What is the resource depletion method?

It’s Bustamante’s idea that people can maintain a polished persona while their time, energy and money are plentiful, but show their natural tendencies when those resources run low. Research shows sleep loss weakens emotional control, though the classic laboratory “ego depletion” effect failed a large replication, so it works best as a practical lens.

What are the four temperaments: Lion, Fox, Cheetah and Bear?

In Bustamante’s team framework, Lions are organisers who plan and structure, Foxes are creators who generate ideas, Cheetahs are executors who decide fast and act, and Bears are relationship builders who hold teams together. He argues that a high-performing team needs all four, so leaders should recruit for whichever is missing.

Can you tell when someone is lying by their body language?

Rarely. A review by Charles Bond and Bella DePaulo of studies involving more than 24,000 judges found people correctly identify lies and truths only about 54 per cent of the time, and experts don’t reliably do better. Inconsistencies in someone’s account over time are more informative than single body-language cues.

Is the Myers-Briggs test accurate?

Personality researchers are sceptical. Critics such as psychologist Ronald Riggio note that the Myers-Briggs sorts people into categories when traits like introversion are continuous, that results can change on retesting, and that there’s little evidence it predicts job performance. It can still be a useful conversation starter if you treat it as a map rather than a verdict.

References

  1. Bustamante, A. (n.d.). The ultimate CIA test to reveal your personality type [Video]. YouTube.
  2. Bustamante, A. (2026). Outsmart everyone: Spy skills to gain an unfair advantage in work and life. Hachette.
  3. Yoo, S.-S., Gujar, N., Hu, P., Jolesz, F. A., & Walker, M. P. (2007). The human emotional brain without sleep: A prefrontal amygdala disconnect. Current Biology, 17(20).
  4. Hagger, M. S., Chatzisarantis, N. L. D., Alberts, H., Anggono, C. O., et al. (2016). A multilab preregistered replication of the ego-depletion effect. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 11(4), 546–573.
  5. Bond, C. F., Jr., & DePaulo, B. M. (2006). Accuracy of deception judgments. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 10(3), 214–234.
  6. Riggio, R. E. (2014, February 21). The truth about Myers-Briggs types. Psychology Today.

Understanding people isn’t about manipulation—it’s about connection, communication, and creating environments where everyone can contribute their unique strengths. Master these techniques to build better teams, conduct more effective interviews, and develop deeper relationships in every area of life.

Source: The ULTIMATE CIA Test To Reveal Your Personality Type with Andrew Bustamante

Follow us on Social Media