Marriages fail today mostly because we expect more from a spouse than ever before while the outside supports and pressures that once held couples together have fallen away. The famous “half of all marriages end in divorce” figure is out of date, yet plenty of marriages still quietly fail long before any paperwork. This article follows psychologist Orion Taraban’s blunt explanation, that modern marriage asks one person to be an entire village, checks his main claims against the evidence, and ends with what a man can actually do about it.
It’s a Thursday night and Tom is sitting at the kitchen table after his wife has gone to bed. Thirty-eight, married eleven years, two kids asleep upstairs. Nothing is wrong, exactly. There was no fight tonight. But he realises, scrolling back through their messages, that every one of them in the last month has been logistics: pick-ups, a boiler engineer, her mother’s birthday. He tries to remember the last time they talked about anything that wasn’t a task. He tries to remember the last time he talked to anyone, about anything real, who wasn’t her. He can’t.
Tom isn’t in a failing marriage. Not yet. But he’s standing at the exact spot where many failing marriages begin.
Why Do Marriages Fail Today?
Most modern marriages fail because expectations have risen sharply, outside constraints have weakened, couples spend less time investing in each other, and partners change in different directions without noticing. It’s rarely one dramatic betrayal. It’s usually a slow mismatch between what the marriage is asked to provide and what the two people are putting into it.
Clinical psychologist Orion Taraban, host of the PsycHacks podcast and a licensed psychologist in California, made the case bluntly in a conversation on Sean Kim’s Growth Minds podcast. In his telling, modern marriage asks one person to be an entire village, and the constraints that once kept couples together have fallen away. Parts of his argument hold up very well against the research. Others need a calmer second look. This article goes through both.
If you’ve watched a marriage unravel, your parents’, a friend’s, perhaps your own, you may carry a quiet question about whether this is something you could get right. It’s a fair question, and a common one. A marriage ending isn’t proof that anyone was foolish, and the patterns behind it are more learnable than the folklore suggests.
The Divorce Rate Myth: What the Numbers Actually Say
The line everyone repeats, that half of all marriages end in divorce, comes from projections made around the divorce peak of the early 1980s. It no longer describes reality.
The National Center for Family and Marriage Research at Bowling Green State University reports a refined divorce rate of 14.2 divorces per 1,000 married women in 2024, down from about 22.6 in 1980: the lowest level in more than half a century. Researchers now estimate that roughly 40 per cent of first marriages will end in divorce, not 50, and second marriages carry a higher risk than first ones. Part of the decline is simply that people are marrying later and more selectively.
Two caveats keep this from becoming a victory lap. Divorce statistics don’t capture the breakups of couples who live together without marrying, and fewer people are marrying at all. Nor do they say anything about marriages that survive on paper while feeling empty, which is the kind Tom is drifting towards. So the useful reading is this: the headline risk is lower than the myth suggests, while the quality of many marriages is the real question. That gap between the myth and the reality is also part of why some men have grown cynical, a mood explored in why some men are walking away from dating and marriage altogether. If you’re weighing whether marriage is worth the risk at all, our realistic risk-reward analysis of marriage covers that question directly.
Why Marriage Held Together Before: Constraints, Not Better Love
When people romanticise the good old days, Taraban argues, they miss what actually kept earlier marriages intact. Previous generations lived with far fewer alternatives, in small and immobile communities. Divorce carried heavy social stigma. Legal and economic barriers left many women without credit, property or independent income. In his view, many of those marriages lasted because leaving was too costly, not because the love was deeper.
His challenge is worth taking seriously: do we want marriages sustained by a lack of options, or do we need a model that suits the conditions we actually live in?
This is the strongest part of his argument, because it explains why marriages can become less stable even when people want commitment as much as ever. It also separates two questions that tend to get fused. Whether marriages are happier now is a different question from whether they last longer. The answer to the first, as we’ll see, is that the best marriages today may be better than ever, while the average one is under more strain.
None of this means the old constraints were good. A marriage held together only by stigma and dependence is its own kind of failure, just a quieter one. What it does mean is that the modern marriage has to be held together by something else, chosen on purpose, because the scaffolding has gone.
Needing Each Other Less: Wealth, Independence and the Evidence
Taraban describes a broader shift in which wealthier societies need each other less in practical, daily terms. When people can buy services, outsource care and meet social needs through markets and screens, the tight communal webs of poorer communities loosen. Neighbours stop borrowing tools. Extended family moves away. Friendship becomes optional rather than essential. The practical counterweight is what we call social wealth: a deliberate network of people you can rely on, built because you can no longer assume it will simply exist.
He also points to women’s financial independence as the most significant change, reasoning that a woman who earns her own money has one less reason to need any particular man.
This is where the evidence pushes back. Sociologist Alexandra Killewald at Harvard University analysed data on more than 6,300 couples followed over several decades and found that, for couples married since the mid-1970s, neither a wife’s full-time employment nor her ability to support herself after a divorce predicted whether the marriage lasted. Sharing housework more evenly didn’t predict divorce either. What did predict higher risk was a husband not working full time. In other words, the old expectation that the man is the breadwinner still shapes marriages strongly, even as other norms have shifted.
For a man, that’s a striking finding, and an uncomfortable one. It suggests the pressure many men feel to provide isn’t imagined; it’s measurable. It also suggests that the problem isn’t women’s independence as such. The bigger risk sits in the gap between changing roles and unchanged expectations, which is something a couple can talk about openly rather than suffer through in silence. Our piece on the hidden costs of career success explores the other side of that pressure: what men give up chasing the role they think is expected of them.
The Suffocation Problem: One Person Cannot Be a Village
Taraban’s most useful idea is that we’ve asked marriage to become a whole village. He calls modern marriage “hyperconflated”: one relationship is expected to be best friendship, romance, sexual partnership, co-parenting, financial partnership, emotional support and personal-growth coaching, all at once. In the past, many of those needs were spread across a wide circle of relatives, friends, neighbours, congregations and clubs. Now they’re piled onto one person.
Psychologist Eli Finkel at Northwestern University reached a strikingly similar conclusion in his research on what he calls the suffocation of marriage. Drawing on history, sociology and psychology, Finkel and his colleagues argue that American marriage has climbed up Maslow’s hierarchy of needs: from survival and safety, to love, to self-expression and personal growth. The higher goals can produce the best marriages in history. But they also demand far more time, attention and emotional investment. When couples pursue those lofty goals while investing less in the relationship, because work, children and screens are eating the hours, the marriage runs short of oxygen.
That’s exactly Tom’s situation. His marriage isn’t failing because he and his wife don’t love each other. It’s straining because she has become his only real friend, his only confidante and his only source of emotional support, while the two of them spend almost no unscheduled time together.
The answer isn’t to expect less of your marriage, though some couples choose that. It’s to give it more oxygen while taking some weight off. More time alone together, protected like any other appointment. And a wider circle, so your spouse isn’t the only person who knows what’s going on inside you. If your friendships have thinned out, maintaining adult friendships is one of the most practical things you can do for your marriage, and a friendship audit at 40 is a good place to start. Burnout matters here too: a man running on empty has no oxygen to give, which is why it pays to notice the early signs of burnout before your marriage does.
The Paradox of Getting What You Want
Taraban makes another provocative point. Relationships often begin with clear shared goals: companionship, children, a home, financial security. Once those goals are achieved, he suggests, a relationship can lose its sense of direction. The couple has reached the destination and has no idea what to do next.
That matches something many married men will recognise. The early years are full of projects, and the projects bind you together. Then the house is bought, the children are in school, the careers have settled, and two people look up and realise they’ve been working side by side for years without facing each other.
There’s a gentler reading of the same pattern. Marriage researcher John Gottman has long emphasised what he calls shared meaning: the rituals, roles and goals a couple builds together on purpose. From that angle, the problem isn’t that achieving goals ruins a marriage. It’s that a marriage built only around external goals runs out of fuel when those goals are met, and needs new ones, chosen together. The same dynamic plays out at a societal scale in why young women are unhappy despite having more freedom than ever: getting what you were told to want doesn’t guarantee meaning.
For a man, the practical question is simple. What are the two of you building now? If the honest answer is “nothing in particular”, that’s not a crisis. It’s an invitation.
Growing Apart, Therapy and the Question of Failure
Taraban also notes that people change. The person you married at twenty-seven may not be the person you’re married to at forty-five, and neither are you. Two people growing in different directions isn’t anyone’s fault, but it can quietly pull a marriage apart. Old patterns from childhood play a part too: the attachment styles each partner brings shape how they reach for each other, or pull away, under stress.
He goes further on one point, suggesting that the fastest way to accelerate a divorce is for one partner to start therapy. His reasoning is that therapy can change one person faster than the marriage can adapt. That’s a sharp clinical observation about what can happen, and it’s worth taking seriously as a warning. But it isn’t what the evidence shows on average. Reviews of couple therapy generally find that most distressed couples benefit from it, though some gains fade over time, and there’s no good evidence that therapy causes divorce. Individual therapy that changes one partner without involving the other is a different matter, which is part of why many therapists encourage couples to grow together rather than separately.
Finally, Taraban offers a provocation that many people find freeing: a marriage that served its purpose didn’t necessarily fail simply because it ended. There’s truth in that. Two people who raised children well, supported each other through hard years and parted with respect haven’t failed at everything.
The calmer counterpoint is that many unhappy marriages don’t stay unhappy. Large studies have found that a majority of people who rated their marriages as unhappy, and stayed, described them as happy several years later. Both leaving and staying can be legitimate choices. The mistake is to assume that today’s unhappiness is permanent, and to decide on that basis. If you’re facing that question now, knowing when to let go of a relationship and the hard conversation you’ve been avoiding are better next steps than a decision made at midnight.
The Incentive Question: Who Gains and Who Loses
Taraban argues that divorce is financially attractive for women and costly for men, and that this imbalance shapes behaviour. It’s one of the parts of his case that men find most persuasive, and most painful.
The evidence gives a more mixed picture. Sociologist Thomas Leopold, using long-running German panel data, followed thousands of married people and compared those who divorced with those who didn’t across twenty different outcomes. Men tended to take the bigger short-term hit to their well-being and life satisfaction, but they recovered. Women’s disadvantage was concentrated in household income and the risk of poverty, and it lasted much longer. Leopold summarised it this way: men’s extra strain from divorce tends to be transient, while women’s tends to be chronic.
That doesn’t erase what many men experience. Losing daily contact with children, losing a home, paying support while rebuilding: these costs are real, and they can be devastating. Our piece on marriage tips from a divorce lawyer looks at the economics of lasting love from the inside. But the research suggests that “women profit from divorce” is too simple. On average, both sides lose, in different currencies and on different timelines.
There’s also a deeper problem with incentive explanations. They assume people leave marriages mainly because the numbers work. What people actually report wanting, when they leave, is usually connection, respect and a sense of being known. Incentives shape the edges of these decisions. They rarely explain the centre.
This section is general information, not legal or financial advice. Divorce law and outcomes vary widely by country and state; speak to a qualified professional about your own situation.
The Monogamy Question
Taraban also questions whether lifelong monogamy suits human nature, pointing to arguments popularised in Christopher Ryan and Cacilda Jethá’s book Sex at Dawn, and to Esther Perel’s idea of the “monogamish” couple, who are mostly but not strictly monogamous.
These ideas are contested, and it’s worth saying so plainly. Sex at Dawn has been heavily criticised by anthropologists and evolutionary scientists, and the evidence about humanity’s ancestral mating patterns is far from settled. Men do tend to want sexual variety, as we discuss in why men want sexual variety, and sexual competition has shaped both sexes. But wanting something isn’t the same as being built for it, and humans are also capable of deep pair bonds.
The practical point for most married men isn’t philosophical. It’s that temptation tends to grow with opportunity, distance and unmet needs. Monogamy doesn’t maintain itself. It needs guardrails: honesty about attraction, limits on situations that blur lines, and a marriage where sex and affection are tended rather than assumed. Part of that is learning the difference between real chemistry and emotional attachment, so that a spark with someone new isn’t mistaken for a verdict on your marriage.
Staying Together for the Kids
Taraban challenges the old idea that parents should stay together for the sake of their children. In homes full of hostility, he has a strong point. Children exposed to chronic, open conflict between their parents don’t do well, and for them a separation can be a relief.
But the research adds an important qualification. In a long-running national study of families followed over many years, sociologists Paul Amato and Alan Booth found that children whose parents ended high-conflict marriages often did better afterwards. Children whose parents ended low-conflict marriages, the quiet, “we’ve just grown apart” kind, often did worse. Those children typically hadn’t seen it coming, and the divorce felt like the ground disappearing beneath them. Amato and Booth estimated that most divorces involving children fall into that lower-conflict category.
So the honest answer depends on the marriage. Where there’s abuse or danger, safety comes first, always, and staying for the children isn’t a virtue. Where the marriage is distant but not hostile, the case for trying hard to repair it before leaving is stronger than popular culture usually admits. Either way, what matters most to children is a father who is actually present, which is why what the data shows about the engaged father is worth reading whatever your situation.
Designing a Marriage on Purpose
Taraban’s most constructive idea is that couples no longer have to accept marriage as a fixed package. Since the old constraints have gone, they can choose which elements to keep, discuss them openly and design a marriage that fits them. He also recommends waiting until at least thirty-five to marry, on the grounds that people know themselves better by then.
The first idea is excellent. The second needs some context. Demographic research generally finds that divorce risk falls sharply for people who marry in their late twenties rather than their teens or early twenties, and then levels off; some analyses suggest it rises slightly again after the early thirties. Age itself isn’t the magic ingredient. What seems to matter is readiness: knowing who you are, what you want and what you can give, which some people reach at twenty-seven and others at forty. That’s also the heart of playing the long game in dating: choosing with open eyes, rather than at a particular age.
Designing a marriage on purpose means talking about the things most couples assume. How you’ll handle money. How much time you’ll protect for each other. What you each need from friends and family, so the marriage doesn’t have to supply everything. What happens when one of you changes. It’s less romantic than a proposal, and more useful.
What This Means for You: Build a Village Around Your Marriage
Back to Tom at the kitchen table. Nothing he’s read here says his marriage is doomed. What it says is that his marriage is carrying too much weight with too little oxygen, and that both of those things can change.
Here’s a ten-minute exercise worth doing this week. Write down everything you expect your partner to be for you: best friend, lover, confidante, co-parent, adviser, cheerleader, the person who calms you down. Then, next to each one, mark which of those needs a friend, a brother, a mentor, a community or a routine could share. You’ll probably find your marriage is holding a lot that was never meant to be held by one person.
Then take one small step. Message an old friend. Book an evening alone with your wife that isn’t about logistics. Ask someone you trust for advice instead of carrying a problem home. If asking feels hard, how to ask for help without manipulating anyone is a useful guide, and learning to let go of outcomes will make it easier to start before you’re sure it’ll work. Love, in the end, is something you practise rather than something you hold, which is why it helps to build a relationship with love, not just with a person. And if your marriage is already in real difficulty, a good couples therapist, a mentor or a trusted friend is a sign of strength, not defeat.
Marriage has lost the walls that once held it up. That’s a loss, but also an opportunity: what holds it up now can be chosen. So the question to take with you, tonight or at your own kitchen table, is simple. What need are you asking one person to meet that a wider circle could share?
Frequently Asked Questions About Why Marriages Fail
Do half of all marriages end in divorce?
No. The “50 per cent” figure comes from projections made around the divorce peak of the early 1980s. The US refined divorce rate fell to 14.2 divorces per 1,000 married women in 2024, its lowest level in more than 50 years, and researchers now estimate that about 40 per cent of first marriages will end in divorce. Second marriages carry a higher risk.
Why do marriages fail today?
Most marriages fail because expectations of a spouse have risen sharply while couples invest less time in each other and the outside pressures that once kept couples together have weakened. Psychologist Eli Finkel calls this the suffocation of marriage. Partners growing in different directions, unmet needs that no single person can fill, and slow emotional distance usually matter more than one dramatic event.
Does women’s financial independence cause divorce?
The evidence says no, at least not directly. Harvard sociologist Alexandra Killewald found that, for couples married since the mid-1970s, neither a wife’s full-time employment nor her ability to support herself after divorce predicted whether a marriage lasted. What did predict higher divorce risk was a husband not working full time, suggesting the breadwinner expectation for men remains strong.
Who initiates most divorces?
Women do. Stanford sociologist Michael Rosenfeld’s analysis of the How Couples Meet and Stay Together survey found that women initiated about 69 per cent of divorces. Among unmarried couples, men and women ended relationships at roughly equal rates, and married women reported lower relationship quality than married men, which suggests something about marriage itself, not just women’s temperament, drives the gap.
Should couples stay together for the kids?
It depends on the marriage. Research by Paul Amato and Alan Booth found that children often did better when high-conflict marriages ended but worse when low-conflict marriages ended, partly because they didn’t see it coming. Where there is abuse, safety comes first. Where a marriage is distant rather than hostile, a serious attempt at repair usually serves children well.
Does couples therapy cause divorce?
There’s no good evidence that it does. A 2020 meta-analysis of 58 studies found that couple therapy has a large effect on relationship satisfaction, and reviews suggest most distressed couples benefit, although gains fade for some couples after treatment ends. Therapy is most effective when both partners take part and start before resentment has hardened.
References
Amato, P. R., & Booth, A. (1997). A generation at risk: Growing up in an era of family upheaval. Harvard University Press.
Finkel, E. J., Hui, C. M., Carswell, K. L., & Larson, G. M. (2014). The suffocation of marriage: Climbing Mount Maslow without enough oxygen. Psychological Inquiry, 25(1).
Killewald, A. (2016). Money, work, and marital stability: Assessing change in the gendered determinants of divorce. American Sociological Review, 81(4), 696–719.
Leopold, T. (2018). Gender differences in the consequences of divorce: A study of multiple outcomes. Demography, 55(3), 769–797.
National Center for Family and Marriage Research. (2025). Refined divorce rate in the U.S.: Geographic variation, 2024 (Family Profile FP-25-31). Bowling Green State University.
Roddy, M. K., Walsh, L. M., Rothman, K., Hatch, S. G., & Doss, B. D. (2020). Meta-analysis of couple therapy: Effects across outcomes, designs, timeframes, and other moderators. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 88(7), 583–596.
Rosenfeld, M. J. (2015, August 22). Who wants the breakup? Gender and breakup in heterosexual couples [Paper presentation]. American Sociological Association 110th Annual Meeting, Chicago, IL, United States.
Waite, L. J., Browning, D., Doherty, W. J., Gallagher, M., Luo, Y., & Stanley, S. M. (2002). Does divorce make people happy? Findings from a study of unhappy marriages. Institute for American Values.
Wolfinger, N. H. (2015). Want to avoid divorce? Wait to get married, but not too long. Institute for Family Studies.




