People insult others mostly when they feel insecure about their own standing; an insult is usually an attempt to climb by pushing someone else down, which is why it reveals more about the speaker than the target. Drawing on philosopher William B. Irvine’s A Slap in the Face: Why Insults Hurt—and Why They Shouldn’t and decades of psychology research, this piece maps the twelve most common motives behind cruel words, from status anxiety and displaced anger to trolling and tribal hostility. Once you can see which motive is driving a remark, it becomes much harder for that remark to land.
The short answer: insults are status moves
Every human group sorts itself into some kind of order, and we are acutely sensitive to where we stand in it. Irvine’s central argument in A Slap in the Face is that insults are tools in this ongoing contest. Where other primates settle rank with displays and physical confrontation, humans developed language and learned to do the same work with words. A put-down is a bid to lower someone’s position, and by contrast to raise your own.
Most of the time this isn’t conscious. Nobody wakes up planning to demote a colleague with a sarcastic aside. But the instinct to monitor and defend status runs constantly in the background, and when it feels threatened, it reaches for the cheapest weapon available.
That gives us the most useful single fact about insults: people who feel secure in their standing rarely need to attack anyone. The man who is comfortable with himself has little reason to make you smaller. When someone repeatedly reaches for put-downs, the question worth asking is not “what’s wrong with me?” but “what is this person afraid of losing?”
The twelve motives below are the common answers.
1. The pecking order: insults as verbal dominance
The simplest motive is the oldest. In any group, from schoolyards to boardrooms, people jostle for rank, and insults are how much of that jostling happens. The joke at someone’s expense in a meeting, the dismissive comment about a rival’s idea, the “banter” that always seems to target the same person: these are dominance displays translated into speech.
Irvine calls the whole contest the social hierarchy game, and his point is that most of us are playing it far more than we realise. Recognising it doesn’t mean you’ll never be targeted. It means you can see the move for what it is, a bid for position, rather than an objective verdict on your worth.
2. Status insecurity: the root of most insults
If the pecking order explains the arena, status insecurity explains who throws the punches. People insult most when they feel their position slipping or under threat. A man who has just been criticised by his boss comes home and snaps at his partner. A driver cut off in traffic unleashes abuse on a stranger he’ll never see again. Neither situation calls for an insult; both involve a sudden blow to someone’s sense of standing.
Research supports the link. In two 1998 studies with 540 students, Brad Bushman and Roy Baumeister found that ordinary self-esteem had little relationship to aggression after criticism. What predicted the harshest retaliation was a strong need to see oneself as superior. It’s not confident people who lash out hardest; it’s people whose confidence is inflated and fragile, and therefore always in need of defending.
3. Fragile grandiosity: when others are props
Some people insult others routinely, not in response to a specific threat but as a way of life. In their story, other people exist to make them look larger. Belittling you keeps their self-image intact.
The pattern is recognisable without diagnosing anyone: the put-downs are constant, they flow one way, and rational responses rarely change them, because the insults serve an inner need rather than any real disagreement. This is also why people with the most inflated self-image tend to be the most sensitive to criticism themselves. Arguing with the content of their insults misses the point. The content was never the point.
4. Displaced aggression: anger that lands on the nearest target
Anger that can’t safely reach its real source often finds another one. The employee humiliated by a manager he can’t confront goes home and criticises his son’s homework. The stressed father snaps at his children. The man who feels powerless in his life becomes cutting with the waiter.
Psychologists call this displaced aggression, and it is well documented. A 2000 meta-analysis led by Amy Marcus-Newhall reviewed 82 studies and found a reliable, moderate effect: provoked people were significantly more likely to aggress against an innocent target than unprovoked people were. If you’re on the receiving end of a sudden insult that seems out of proportion, there’s a real chance you’re standing in for someone else. And if you notice yourself doing it, the cutting remark is a signal that some other anger needs a better outlet than the person in front of you. Often what sits under the anger is something quieter, such as shame, fear or exhaustion, which is the logic behind the anger iceberg.
5. Pain projection: spreading hurt to feel less alone
Irvine observes that people who are hurting sometimes wound others to feel less alone with their pain, or to restore a sense of balance by bringing someone else down to their level. Misery, in the old phrase, loves company.
He also identifies a subtler version: the relayed insult. “I thought you should know what he said about you.” The messenger spreads the harm while appearing helpful, and sometimes the relaying is the real hostility. It’s fair to ask anyone who delivers someone else’s insult why they felt you needed to hear it.
Understanding pain projection doesn’t oblige you to absorb it. You can recognise that someone is hurting and still decline to be the place they put it.
6. Control: insults as a tool of power
In unequal relationships, insults often maintain the hierarchy. A steady stream of put-downs from a boss, a parent or a partner discourages challenge and slowly erodes the target’s confidence. Over time, the person on the receiving end can begin to believe the verdicts, which makes it harder to push back or leave.
This is the point where insults stop being an annoyance and become something more serious. Repeated belittling that wears down your sense of self is one of the emotional manipulation patterns men often miss, and certain recurring lines are worth learning to recognise, as in this list of manipulative phrases that undermine healthy communication. If this describes a relationship you’re in, it deserves more than a Stoic shrug. Talk to someone you trust about what’s happening, and if it’s affecting your wellbeing, a counsellor can help you see the pattern clearly.
7. Testing the bond: teasing between equals
Not every barb is hostile. Among close friends, teasing can be a sign of trust: I know you well enough to joke about this, and I trust you can take it. Research on teasing by the Berkeley psychologist Dacher Keltner and colleagues found that playful teasing often strengthens relationships, and that the way people tease tends to track status. Teasing between friends and equals is more affectionate, while teasing down a hierarchy tends to carry more of an edge.
That’s why the same joke can feel warm from an old friend and insulting from a new acquaintance who hasn’t earned the licence. Context, history and power decide whether words bond or wound, and it’s why some jokes feel like attacks even when the speaker insists they were harmless.
8. Humour and entertainment: insults as performance
Roasts, comedy specials and the witty put-down at the dinner table all turn insults into entertainment. Sometimes everyone is genuinely in on the joke. Sometimes the audience laughs while the target smiles through real hurt, because objecting would make them look humourless.
Historically, court jesters had a licence to mock the powerful, which could serve a useful purpose by saying what no one else dared. But humour can also disguise cruelty, giving the speaker cover (“it was just a joke”) for remarks that would be unacceptable if said plainly. A useful test: would the line still be said if it couldn’t be passed off as humour?
9. Passive aggression: resentment in disguise
Unexpressed resentment rarely disappears. It tends to leak out sideways, as sarcasm, pointed “jokes” and backhanded compliments. “You look great for your age.” “Nice work, for a first attempt.”
These remarks are hard to address precisely because they’re deniable. Research by Ovul Sezer, Alison Wood Brooks and Michael Norton at Harvard found that people use backhanded compliments to seem likeable and high-status at the same time, especially when they feel their own standing is threatened. It usually backfires: recipients and bystanders judge the giver as less sincere and less competent. There’s more on why they sting in the psychology of backhanded compliments.
10. Downward comparison: shrinking others to feel bigger
When someone else’s success highlights our own shortfalls, one way to restore comfort is to diminish their achievement. He only got promoted because of who he knows. She’s obsessed with the gym. He got lucky.
These are insults of comparison. They protect the speaker’s self-esteem by redefining someone else’s win as unearned or unhealthy. If you notice yourself doing it, it’s worth asking what the other person’s success has stirred up in you; the comparison trap usually tells you something about your own unmet ambitions.
11. Tribal hostility: insults that bind the in-group
Insulting outsiders is one of the oldest ways to strengthen loyalty within a group. Mocking the rival team, the other political party, the other neighbourhood: these insults aren’t really aimed at individuals. They signal membership. They say, “I’m one of us.”
The instinct makes evolutionary sense, since group cohesion once meant survival. But it also explains a great deal of modern prejudice and political hostility, where people direct contempt at entire categories of strangers they’ve never met. When an insult targets a group rather than a person, it’s usually doing identity work for the speaker’s tribe.
12. Online disinhibition and trolling: insults without consequences
The internet has added a motive the ancient Stoics never had to consider. The psychologist John Suler described what he called the online disinhibition effect: anonymity, invisibility and the absence of immediate consequences lead many people to say things online they would never say face to face. Ordinary people become harsher behind a screen.
A smaller group goes further. A 2014 study by Erin Buckels, Paul Trapnell and Delroy Paulhus found that people who enjoy trolling score higher on the so-called “dark” personality traits, with sadism, enjoyment of others’ distress, showing the strongest link. For these people, the insult isn’t a status move or a projection of pain; the reaction is the reward. The practical lesson is the same one the Stoics would give: don’t supply the reaction.
Culture changes what counts as an insult
What wounds in one culture can be neutral in another. Direct criticism may read as honest and respectful in one place and humiliating in another. Sarcasm can be affectionate in one family and cruel in the next. And in cultures with strong honour codes, an insult may carry a social obligation to respond that simply doesn’t exist elsewhere.
This matters because some of what you experience as insults may not have been intended as attacks at all. Irvine defines an insult by its effect rather than its intent, which means misreadings are common. Before deciding a remark was hostile, it’s worth considering whether the speaker was simply speaking a different social language.
Patterns of the chronic insulter
People who insult frequently tend to share a recognisable set of patterns: high anxiety about status, difficulty regulating emotions, limited empathy, and often a history of having been put down themselves. This is a description of behaviour, not a diagnosis, and it doesn’t excuse anything. But it does reframe the experience of being their target.
When the insults are constant, they say very little about you and a great deal about the speaker’s inner state. Some people are, as the old fable puts it, destructive even when it makes no sense. Recognising that is not cynicism; it’s accuracy. And it opens the practical question of how much access such a person should have to you, which is where the work of dealing with toxic people begins.
Breaking the cycle (including in yourself)
It’s worth being honest: almost everyone has insulted someone. The cutting remark to a partner after a bad day, the dismissive comment about a colleague’s promotion, the joke that went one step too far. Understanding why people insult others is also a way of understanding ourselves, and none of it is a reason for self-punishment. These patterns are common, and they’re learnable.
Here’s a small practice that works in both directions. Before you say something sharp, pause and ask one question: what need would this remark serve? Status, relief, revenge, belonging? Most of the time the honest answer is enough to change what you say. And when you’re on the receiving end, ask the mirror question: whose pain is this? Is the remark really about you, or about the speaker’s day, insecurity or anger? Answer it honestly, decide whether there’s anything to do (a boundary to set, a piece of feedback to use), and then let the rest go.
You’ve already done a version of this. There’s someone whose jabs used to ruin your mood and now barely register, because at some point you understood what drove them. That understanding was the skill. The practice simply makes it deliberate.
The liberation of understanding
Irvine’s deepest point is that insults hurt in proportion to the authority we give them. Once you see that most insults are status bids, displaced anger, projected pain or bids for control, they lose much of their power, not because you’ve grown thicker skin, but because you’ve stopped treating them as verdicts. That’s the heart of how Stoic philosophy makes you harder to insult without emotional detachment.
Understanding is not the same as tolerating. You can see clearly why someone insults you and still set a firm boundary, walk away, or end the relationship. What changes is the internal experience: the remark becomes information about the speaker rather than a wound to carry home. If you want the practical toolkit for the moment itself, six Stoic strategies for responding to insults covers the specific moves, and the full summary of A Slap in the Face lays out all 33 of Irvine’s lessons.
You can’t control why other people reach for cruel words. You can control whether those words get to decide how your evening goes. So the next time a remark stings, try asking a different question than the one that usually comes first: what was this person trying to protect?
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do people insult others?
Most insults are attempts to protect or raise the speaker’s social standing by lowering someone else’s. Common motives include status insecurity, displaced anger, projecting personal pain, maintaining control in a relationship, envy and downward comparison, group loyalty, and, online, the disinhibition that comes with anonymity.
What does it mean when someone insults you all the time?
Frequent insults usually say more about the speaker than the target. Chronic insulters often show high status anxiety, poor emotional regulation and low empathy. If the insults are constant and wear down your confidence, they may be a form of control, and it’s worth discussing the situation with someone you trust.
Is insulting someone a sign of insecurity?
Often, yes. Research by Bushman and Baumeister found that a fragile, inflated sense of superiority, rather than ordinary self-esteem, predicted the most aggressive responses to criticism. People who feel secure in their standing rarely need to diminish others.
What is the difference between teasing and insulting?
Teasing between equals and close friends is usually affectionate and can strengthen bonds. The same words become insulting when there’s a power imbalance, no established trust, or when the target is genuinely hurt but feels unable to object. Context, relationship and intent decide which it is.
Why do people insult others online?
The online disinhibition effect means anonymity and the absence of face-to-face consequences make people harsher than they would be in person. A smaller group of persistent trolls score higher on traits like sadism and enjoy provoking distress, which is why not reacting is usually the most effective response.




